.

BLOG: Maybe it Wasn't Reagan

Maybe Reagan wasn't such a great president. Maybe Reagan was just a vessel.

This November 6th, we will elect a new president. We have confidence that whoever we choose will take us in the direction promised in the campaign, but in reality, we know it's not that simple.  It ignores the central role that public opinion plays in American politics.

President Obama made many promises 2008. I have no doubt that he earnestly wanted to fulfill his promises, but in many cases, he was thwarted. He would like us to believe it was the "other party" that thwarted him, but that's not the case. The reason he was unable to keep many of his promises is that public opinion stood in his way. At every turn-closing Gitmo, holding trials for terrorists in New York, the DREAM act -  attempts to keep promises were derailed by public opinion, and the efficient pandering machine that is Congress.

In our governments - federal, state, and local - very little happens without the assent of the people. Politicians are nothing if not masters of the art of sensing public approval. Those who do not have this gift do not stay in office long. Politicians are acutely aware of the mood of the public, and don't wait until election time to take action. Pandering is a 24/7, full contact sport in Washington DC.

Presidents do it too, and not just in election years.  Their words and actions have enormous influence on the success of politicians at all levels, especially those from the same political party. Political allies depend on the president's success, and the president depends on them.  Presidents do not, and cannot act alone.

Ronald Reagan is beloved by conservatives as a leader and transformational figure.  Conservatives see him as a revolutionary, turning back the tide of pessimism and government overreach in the 1980s, and opening an era of prosperity. However, I wonder if Reagan gets too much credit. The tremendous sensitivity of congress to public opinion was no less in 1980 than it is today. Congress has been in the business of getting re-elected since the beginning of the republic.  Ronald Reagan didn't even have a majority in Congress to support him, yet he got major legislation passed early in his term to enact his agenda.

It may be that we have it backwards. Maybe it wasn't so much Reagan who led us out from under President Carter's malaise. Maybe Reagan was more a talented man in the right place, at the right time. He caught the mood of the people, and so did congress.  The people were sick of being told that they were in decline, that their best days were behind them, and that they could not fix it themselves.

Maybe Reagan didn't lead as much as follow. He didn't create the ideology that he championed. Maybe his role was to crystalize the will of the people into magnificent rhetoric and put it into action.  Maybe he was little more than a superb vessel.

Mitt Romney has worked hard to be a "moderate," much to the chagrin of many conservatives.  While this choice makes him a suboptimal choice for those "real" conservatives, it makes him an excellent vessel. His job, as with all politicians, is to do the will of the people. What better way to do this than to elect a man ready to carry out the wishes of the people, without too many preconceived notions of what must be done.

As with Reagan, maybe we are not choosing a leader who will take us somewhere, but a politician who will reflect our will, and follow our lead.

Maybe we look at elections backwards, too.  Maybe election day is not the end of a process, but the beginning.  If politicians are so sensitive to the wishes of the people, as I believe they are, the people have a responsibility - a duty - to hold their elected representatives' feet to the fire.  As with pandering, accountability should also be a 24/7, full contact sport in America.

Vote carefully on Nov 6th, and remember that no matter who wins, your voice should not fall silent when the returns are in.  

The real work begins on Nov 7th.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Gordon Anderson November 01, 2012 at 08:38 PM
Good thoughts Don. In our system of governance, the President does not lead us like a king, even though we often act like that is his role, and the campaign rhetoric makes it sound like that is his role. The role of the president is to administer the rule of law that the people create, not to rule the people. Having said that, it is important to remember that the legislators we elect pass that rule of law that guides the president on our behalf. When we vote, we need to ask whether those legislators are promoting a principled rule of law, and is the president qualified to be the chief administrator, making sure all departments of government are running smoothly and efficiently.
Donald Lee November 01, 2012 at 09:08 PM
Exactly. The requirements for being an adequate "vessel" are high, as they should be. The president also has a unique role in that he can and does lead us by choosing what to lionize, and what to condemn. His influence is substantial, for good or ill. It is vitally important that we choose well.
Ray November 01, 2012 at 09:37 PM
Um Donald, Reagan had a congress full of Democrats who were willing to work with him. He did not have a speaker who openly states that his only goal is to make the president a one term president.
coachfactoryoutlet November 15, 2012 at 09:17 AM
With so many Christmas gift ideas to choose from Yandy, the site is offering up some suggestions this holiday season for stumped shoppers. Some of the most popular Coach purses choices include a red stretch lace bra and matching strappy booty short set for $19.95 and the ever popular, charmeuse robe and matching chemise set for $19.95. For the more conservative recipient, the sweet sensations satin pajama set, featuring a long sleeve satin sleep shirt and pants, is not only ideal but affordable at $31.95. http://www.uggssaleaustralia.com/
xiaoxian November 18, 2012 at 01:05 AM
http://www.louisvuittononlineshope.com/ louis vuitton outlet online http://www.coachoutletonlinepicks.net/ coach outlet http://www.louisvuittonpursesbag.net/ louis vuitton purses http://www.discountcoachshandbag.com/ discount coach handbags http://www.cheapcoachsbagsusa.org/ http://www.cheapcoachsbagsusa.org http://www.buycoachsoutletonline.org/ coach outlet http://www.greatlouissvuittonbags.org/ louis vuitton purse outlet http://www.coachpurseoutletss.net/ coach handbags outlet http://www.gotocoachsoutlets.net/ coach outlet online

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »